*
Today I've united with twelve favorite food bloggers to bring you a holiday cookie celebration so big, it's being monitored by the North Pole! To see all of the participating blogsites, and to discover seven sweet giveaways, please visit the Baker's Dozen Event Site at http://www.13cookiechristmas.info/
* *
Ten degrees below zero on Tuesday.
And school was called off for the day.
Hooray.
*

John took the boys outside to do a bit of this.

While the littlest boy did a bit of this.
(This is not, technically, helping.)
*
The girls and I stayed inside and worked up a sweat.
After all, someone needed to keep the homefires a'baking.
*
We conjured butter cookies. Wondrous, tender cookies which held a secret withinst their little butter bosoms....
A molten middle. Nada on the inside. Nothing in the center.
Nary a bit of oomph within those little bumps.
*
Which suddenly sounds vexingly autobiographical
(types their creator, as she straightens her very-roomy size AAA brassiere.)
*
Please forgive the above personal moment of self awareness. I sometimes forget how much there is to be learned in one's kitchen.
*
Now...back to the sub-zero cookie making.
*
The butter cookies begged for a fine and shiny frosting.
Seeking something akin to a Victoria's Secret push-up bra
(oh heck, there I go dropping my own issues again),
they were anxious to don some salute-the-sky, high-falutin' fashion.
*
How could we gals resist granting them such humble desires?
There was a horde of hungry shovelers to feed, and we did so want our butter babies to look nice for the menfolk.
Like the long-nailed gals at the beauty parlor, we got them purtied up.
*
The boys burst inside from their snow white shoveling,
gratefully greeted by a plate of eye-popping, jaw-dropping button cookies.
*
It was cold outside.
But, we were warm on the insides.
And that, my friends, was a very merry thing to be on such a day as it was.
*
Very merry, indeed.
Merry & Bright Brown Sugar Butter ButtonsWhen it comes to a cookie exchange, do you ever feel the kid in you sneaking a peek at the offerings? Scanning a table full of goodies, aren't your eyeballs always grabbed by the colorfullest of cookies? The frosted. The fluffy. The frilly.
Wanting to create the very type of cookie that children of all ages might adore, I attempted a butter cookie four times. Some were flat. Some were bloppy. Not a one held their shape through cooking, coming out of the oven like little mini-mounds of holiday happiness.
Until this recipe. This adorable little button of a cookie.
Then...imagine my surprise when I bit into one and discovered the cookies were not only flaky but surprisingly hollowed. Or is that hallowed? Somehow this trait makes them even more perfect for the cookie exchange table. A extra-unique recipe which holds a magical secret. Topped with a glimmering icing, I think you'll find these button cookies are among the first to be snapped up and swallowed down this Christmas. From my kitchen to yours. Merry, Merry Holidays!
1 stick butter, softened
1 c. powdered sugar
1/2 c. brown sugar
1/2 tsp. vanilla
dash of salt
1 c. flour
In a large bowl, use a fork to combine butter, sugars, vanilla and salt. Slowly add the flour, combining thoroughly until a thick dough is formed. Turn out onto countertop. Begin kneading until dough forms a ball. Roll until about 1/2" thick, cut into 1-inch circles. Bake at 300 degrees for 11-13 minutes, or just until the tops of cookies are firm to the touch. Remove. Cool. Frost with Sheeny Butter Icing.
*
Sheeny Butter Icing
Created to be the type of frosting which holds it place, and dries with shine, while still offering a mouthful of incredible flavor. Mission accomplished. You're going to love this frosting.
2 c. powdered sugar
2 T. butter, melted
1 tsp. vanilla
1 T. corn syrup
1 tsp. heavy cream
In a large bowl, combine all ingredients until well mixed. If a thicker consistency is needed, add powdered sugar by the tablespoon. If a thinner consistency is desired, add corn syrup by the teaspoon. Color with your favorite icing colors, pipe, and enjoy!
*
*
Make This Holiday Season the Merriest of All...*
The {mouthwateringly wondrous} Carolina Cookie Company is gifting one lucky commenter with a
12 month Cookie-Of-The-Month membership
Retail value, $293.64

Just imagine. Twelve consecutive months of Carolina Cookie's gourmet, fresh baked cookies in the flavor for the month, arriving at your doorstep. The very thought makes my knees week. It makes my heart flutter. It makes...oh! Why are you listening to my musings, when you could be leaving the winning comment right.now.
To enter, CLICK HERE to peruse the lip-smacking selection of Carolina Cookie's products. Pick your favorite, then come back here and tell me which one most tickled your tastebuds via comment (it's going to be hard to choose just one. Holy cow, they are gorgeous!).
One winner will be chosen at random on 12.14.09. Open to US residents only.
*
WANT EVEN MORE CHANCES TO WIN INCREDIBLE COOKIES?!
Visit the Baker's Dozen event site by clicking HERE to find more incredible Cookie-Of-The-Month giveaways! Six other Baker's Dozen bloggers are offering prizes donated by some of America's BEST bakeries. Be especially sure to catch the incredible giveaway right there, on that main event site! (BIG HINT...scroll to the bottom of THIS PAGE and look to the right! Yummarum!)
207 comments:
«Oldest ‹Older 1 – 200 of 207 Newer› Newest»I love the basics, chocolate chip. I think the kids and I are in for a little baking today.
Oh, Brooke, You are a SCREAM!!!
I think the Dr. Midnight cookies look wonderful! Anything with chocolate wins my heart. :)
Oh i must make these soon!!
The cranberry nut cookie sounds delicious. I recently discovered how much i love dried cranberries, especially in cookies :)
Those look amazing, and love the great pops of color!
Chunky chocolate! Chunky chocolate!
Milk chocolate macadamia nut
That was easy, I would love to have all the tasty cookies in the Student Cookie of the Month club for my son, who's in college for the first time! Anything chocolate and chunky would be delightful!!
Such a sweet post! The pictures are amazing. Love the "the end" shot. Thanks for putting this event together!
Enjoyed your post and I can identify with your frank comment, LOL! I loved the white choc. macademia nut, followed by the triple choc pecan! Yummy!
Carey
Chocolate Macadamia Nut ... I will call you precious and make you my own. You have a fabulous blog - can't believe I am just now finding it.
Jess
The white chocolate macadamia nut cookie, YUM! Love white chocolate. Cute post, maybe I should be more frank in my writing style,,,,,,
What is the texture of this cookie? Are they soft and cake like or hard and crispy? They look terrific!
Mmmm! Butter Pecan is my first pick, but the Oatmeal Raisin sounds super tasty too!
:)
I vote for the snickerdoodles. Doesn't get much better than butter and cinnamon.
Oh my .... the Milk Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookies look FABULOUS!!
Your button cookies are absolutely beautiful. I have a friend who is decorating in lime green and hot pink this Christmas...these will make a perfect little gift for me to share with her. Your recipe came at the perfect time!
I've gotta go with the never fail chocolate chunk, yum!!
For the Carolina Cookies I must choose Butter Pecan. I has always been my favorite ice cream so in a cookie you couldn't go wrong with that flavor..yum yum!
I loved your snowy day story & those cute little button cookies. perfect!
Gotta go w/ the White Choc. Mac Nut cookies.
I am loving the button cookies. They will be great for holiday gifts! I would have to go with the Chunky Reese's Peanut Butter.....I love peanut butter
Love the button cookies....my kids will have a blast decorating them.
I must have the cranberry nut cookies....'cuz as my husband always says, I am a bit fruity and nutty!
I think the reeses peanut butter cup cookies look the most decadent right now. But ask me later and I might tell you a different flavor!
I would have to go with the chocolate chip or Dr. Midnight. Oh how yummy they look! I'm inspired to bake the day away!
I think the Chunk Reeses peanut butter cup cookie looks incredible! My mouth starts watering just looking at all the incredible flavors, but anything with reeses in it I will definitely have to eat:-)
kate.l.ham@gmail.com
Your recipe looks great! I have to go with white choc mac nut. Love those.
I love your colorful cookies!
I couldn't look long at Carolina Cookies because it sends me close to fits over being in front of the computer rather than the oven all day...that happens all too easily! I want them all, but if I had to choose just one it would be chocolate chip pecan...yum!
they would all be very welcome in my mouth, but chunky chocolate kills me.
White Chocolate Macadamia nut
they all look UNBELIEVABLE! normally i'm a dark chocolate kind of gal but i'd have to say the milk chocolate macadamia nut is calling to me this morning. thanks for all your fabulous recipes and ideas :)
LOVE these!!! I have to laugh at your minus ten though... it was minus 20 or so here yesterday - has been more or less all week! Minus 30 with the wind chill. Saturday's high is -21!
Those are the happiest cookies I've ever seen... they made me smile on a cooolllllddd morning!
I suppose "all of the above" is not the best choice??! If I must choose, the white chocolate macadamia nut would be the first one popped in my mouth!
The triple chocolate pecan sound right up my alley. Thanks for the chance to win!
Triple Chocolate Pecan would be my choice, I believe you can hear my tummy growling right now! I too want to take this time to let you know how much fun it is to read Tongue n Cheeky, your recipes, your humor, :) your writings and wonderful pictures make me smile. Thank you.
Chunky Chocolate Pecan cookies sound SO GOOD right now.
my standby favorite is def. white chocolate macadamia but admittedly the butter pecan sounds fabulous! Thanks!
White chocolate macadamia nut are fantastic!
chunky reeses peanut butter! :)
Gotta love oatmeal raisin!
Oh, that Triple Choclate Chunk looks like heaven in your mouth!! Love your cute comments and pix on your blog today! I am making your fantastic looking (smelling and tasting in my mind) butter cookies TODAY!!
Ohhh - Milk Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookies sound amazing. My mouth is watering. :)
Triple chocolate pecan, hands down!
The Oatmeal Cranberry Nut looks super delicious!
That Chunky Milk Chocolate's gonna do it for me! :D
Whicte chocolate macadamia nut are the bomb!
Chunky milk chocolate! It makes me sad that dark chocolate is getting all the fame when milk chocolate at it's finest in a cookie is delectably delicious!
Oh, oatmeal cranberry! I've been cranberry-obsessed lately ...
What a fun blog you have, I'm surprised I haven't found it before! I saw this picture on Tastespotting and it just made me...happy! I'm in love with the color combo of the frosting. Too cute! The cookies sound divine.
The reeses peanut butter cookies sound yummy!
The oatmeal cranberry nut sounds very tempting! Anything with cranberry in it is usually pretty darn tasty.
Would have to be the Milk Chocolate Macadamia ones...and they were also the Cookie of the Month in November so it fits for my birthday month.....
Love your button cookies....will definitely be trying these out
Thanks
I'm a sucker for anything Reeses PB!! So my pick with be the Reeses Peanut Butter Cookies!
What a fantastic blog you have!!
-- Anne
www.EverlastingInk.Blogspot.com
Your butter buttons look great - love your blog!
As for the carolina cookie company, the triple chocolate pecan sounds sinfully good.
The triple chocolate pecan. Yes, that's gotta be the best!
Chunky reese's peanut butter is calling my name...oh please let me be picked :)
The triple Chocolate Pecan look amazing !
milk chocolate macadamia nut. Yum!
Your button cookies look yummy too!
They all sound great but if I had to say just one it would be the Chunky Reeses PB ones. MMMM. Thanks, Maureen (jnomaxx at hotmail dot com)
The Chunky Reese's Peanut Butter ones look amazing!
White Chocolate Macademia Nut!
Ok, first of all, these cookies and your pictures are absolutely gorgeous!! I love those bright colors! I'm having a friend over to bake/decorate cookies next week and I think these will be perfect!
I think I'm going to stick with the good 'ol chocolate chunk cookie - man it looks GOOD!! Great post!
-Amy
www.singforyoursupperblog.com
Oh my, they all look so good! I think I'll pick the triple chocolate pecan!
My e-mail: michelecollins923@hotmail.com
Holy Crap!! Those look gorgeous AND delicious!! I'm def. making these babies, thanks!!!
My fave I think is the butter pecan...yummy!
My mouth is just watering. I will be making those cookies. Tonight. MMMMMM... oh, man, I can't wait!
Oatmeal Cranberry Nut would be my cookie of choice. A little different and quite possibly a perfect standout yummy cookie this holiday season.
The oatmeal raisin cookies look awesome!
Chunky Milk Chocolate for this Carolina Girl!
The white chocolate macadamia nut look delicious!
It would have to be the peanut butter and chocolate chip! Who can go wrong with that combo. :)
mmm. Butter Pecan.
They Chocolate Reesy Peanut Butter Cookies. MMMMMH> YUM!!
These are darling and in perfect time for a cookie exchange I am going to next week. I am curious about how many cookies one batch makes. If you don't eat too many that is!
Can I say February is looking pretty scrumptious. If I win can I get double that month. Triple Chocolate Pecan - all my favorite ingredients in one little cookie!
I cannot believe my luck to come across your post on TasteSpotting. Not only do you offer up one helluva good story, there's a perfect button cookie AND sheeny frosting recipe (which will be a perfect way to use my brand new all-natural food colorings)and what's this? A giveaway?! Are you mad, woman? Anyway, I might as well come clean and say that I am just an out and out chocolate chip cookie fan, and it looks like no less than five months of offerings have me covered there. Thanks for providing such a great visit. (I laughed out loud at that last photo of your son lying on the snow.)
Anyway, I found you through TasteSpotting and am writing to say that if you have any photos that aren’t accepted there, I’d love to publish them. Visit my new site (below), it’s a lot of fun! I hope you will consider it.
Best,
Casey
Editor
www.tastestopping.com
I love chunk and flavor triple chocolate pecan chunk. Yummy.
Oatmeal cranberry nut!
urchiken at gmail dot com
I'm going to have to go with triple chocolate pecan. I can't resist chocolate in any form.
Mmmm...Chunky Chocolate Pecan!!
The butter pecan look delish!
I would have to say that the triple chocolate would be my pick! Love your blog!
Since I am regularly vetoed on nuts in cookies at my house, I would pick the milk chocolate macadamia nut cookie. All of the cookies look delicious.c
A hollow middle...hmm, does that mean they are slightly healthier hehe? I love the color in the photos, it's making me rethink my baking decision for tomorrow!
Oh my, and now that chunky milk chocolate cookie is making me rethink yet again!!
Ooh, the chunky reeses peanut butter is my pick.
member (dot) thao (at) gmail.com
The milk chocolate macadamia nut cookies sound delish!!!
The gingerbread ones look yummy!!!
The Milk Chocolate macadamia nut look great, that's a hard combo to find! Yum!
Chunky Reeses Peanut Butter cookies - WOW!! Thanks for the giveaway!
jmhamlin826 AT yahoo DOT com
Oh, Chunky Chocolate Pecan for sure!
Triple Chocolate Pecan would be my favorite.
Your cookies look amazing. For the contest I'll go with the gingerbread.
Milk Chocolate Macadamia Nut. Yum.
Gingerbread, since I won't be making them this year.
Chocolate chip please! Now I really want a cookie!
The oatmeal cranberry nut cookies looks so yummy...so does everything else for that matter. Good grief!
I have to go with the Chunky milk chocolate.
The chunky chocolate looks too good to pass up!
I would go for the oatmeal cranberry nut!!
Triple chocolate pecan, for sure!
They all look incredible! If I had to narrow it down, I'd go with Chunky Reeses Peanut Butter. YUM!
A simple, sweet sugar cookie for me.
Chunky chocolate, definitely!
I would choose the gingerbread, it looks really good.
chanfamily65@yahoo.com
The Chunky Chocolate Pecan have my name written all over them! Love your cookies and can't wait to try the icing, too! Thanks for a chance at the giveaway.
I am going to try to make these button cookies for my christmas cookie exchange next week! We'll see.
As far as the Carolina Cookie Company those Butter Pecan are calling my name (as are any of them really)! yum
I'll take one of each! Seriously, how fun would a cookie of the month club be?
Butter Pecan, Butter Pecan!
cjcoppola2@yahoo.com
Hands down, chunky milk chocolate!!!
The classy white chocolate macadamia nut...Yum!
sarah.wichmer@gmail.com
I have to say, Chunk Chocolate, all the way. Your cookies above look incredible, by the way. LOVE the colors!
Butter Pecan is my pick. I've always loved butter pecan cookies and ice cream.
Your recipes are great. Thanks for sharing.
TRigell at aol dot com
My top pick is the "Chunky Milk Chocolate". They look thick and chewy and I want one right now! Wow! This is a fantastic giveaway. Came across your site via Tastespotting. Love it.
Thanks!
Triple chocolate pecan. Interestingly, it was the pecans (and not the chocolate, though that helped) that made these beat out oatmeal cranberry nut!
I think I'd like the gingerbread, although it's hard to pick!
My favorite would definitely be the white chocolate macadamia but I really want to try the oatmeal cranberry nut, then the milk chocolate pecan, then ... you're right! How do you choose?
What a great giveaway!
Jen
cjy5787@gmail.com
Oh Oh Oh Oh!
Those cookies are the MOST adorable cookies EVER!!!!
How on earth did you create such vibrant colors?
Those are like the happiest cookies I have ever seen!
Yummmm!
XOOOOXX
Milk chocolate with macadamia....DELIGHTFUL!
Oatmeal Cranberry Chunk for the win!
Yummy for my tummy! I think a bite of each and then I'll let you know!
I think the Chocolate Chunk Pecan wins my vote!
So hard to choose but I do love my chocolate so I will go with Triple Chocolate Pecan! Yummy
tzales13@yahoo.com
Gosh it's so hard to choose.... I would probably grab one of the chunky Milk Chocolate cookies first, then of course try another.... and another.... and another.... and...
I would love some cranberry nut ones!
Your whole post makes me happy! Such a lovely and loving family. Great job on the cookies, they are perfect for dough or/and frosting lovers!!
this contest is amazing!!!! Milk chocolate macadamia nut PLEASE!!! *crosses fingers*
Who can resist a chunky reeses peanut butter cookie! I know I can't. It's my favorite candy!
Umm... *sits by the computer in shock and awe*
Butter pecan?!
BUTTER PECAN!?
I've never heard of such a thing in a cookie. But I imagine it is true delight.
GINGERBREAD woohoo!
Dr. Midnight cookies for me!
Milk chocolate pecan for me please!
Butter Pecan would go great with my favorite ice cream, which just happens to be butter pecan too!
The white chocolate macadamia nut cookie, Although all their cookies look like they would like to add to my hips!
The Butter Pecan got my attention right away. Oh baby.
Chunky milk chocolate please!! Looks and sounds delicous!
amscheetz@yahoo.com
Chunky Chocolate Pecan, no question!!!
Oooh, I like the chunky chocolate pecan!
Ideally, I'd like one of each. Variety is the BEST spice in life, don't you think?
But I'd happily take one of the butter pecan.
We baked simple brownies during our snow day wednesday. These are fabulous looking!
I would have to say the Milk Chocolate Chunk!!! Milk's good for you, right?!?!?!?! ;)
All so tempting! I must choose the triple chocolate pecan - I can't resist a shiny, dark brown, chocolate cookie and the added crunch of tasty pecans is impossible to resist. Yum!
Chunky milk chocolate for sure!
Hands down, the white chocolate macadamia nut. Mmmmm!
Definitely the chunky milk chocolate.
Butter Pecan sounds great to me!
Those cookies are so pretty! You always amaze with your creations. And I laughed out loud at the bra commentary.
I didn't look for my favorite cookies on the other site becaus I try not to have too many opportunities with which to gorge myself with cookies, and a Cookie-of-the-Month membership seems counterproductive to that.
Mmmm, cookies....I thought the chunky chocolate pecan cookies looked wonderful!
nlarma@gmail.com
I have never met a white chocolate macadamia nut cookie that I didn't like!
Butter pecan!
Chunky Reese peanut butter! I'm a sucker for anything with peanut butter in it!
Love the chocolate gingersnaps!
Gingerbread, for sure!
Chunky Chocolate Pecan, please! Yummo!
Definitely the gingerbread cookies. I love making gingerbread every year for my tree. And the cute house that takes hours to make and minutes to destroy - but so worth it :D
Look too pretty to bite, but I would in a blink yummy chocolate make me want to bake
Oatmeal Rasin or Chocolate Chunk or those Macadamia Nut Cookies sound great too...cookies are my achilles heel. make it impossible to lose that 'just had a baby' fat. recently found your blog and I love your sense of humor. {ok. the recipes are great too}
The triple chocolate pecan...looks really, really yummy!
The Reese's chunky chocolate peanut butter cookies look they hide a surprise as delicious as your cookies do!
The sugar cookies are striking my fancy. Buttery sugary deliciousness.
Yours look amazing too!!!
Chunky chocolate pecan looks marvelous. But so do yours! I think they'll be going in my Christmas cookie tins for sure!
Macadamia Nut Cookies sound great!
chunky milk chocolate sounds totally deeeeliciousss
I'm eyeing that chunky reese's peanut butter cookie. Yum!
Mmm....Chunky Reese's Peanut Butter.
MilK Chocolate Macadamia Nut-It gets better with every word!
Definitely chunky chocolate!
JenB.
freejen@comcast.net
I made the button cookies this afternoon as was really disapointed. Yours looked absolutely beautiful. Mine turned into a flat greasy mess. I don't know what I did wrong. I bake all the time and usually have good results. I sorry they didn't work, I loved yours.
Chunky Reeses Peanut Butter! Need I say more! I have reeses stashed all over, I try to forget about them, but they call my name. In a cookie form...That is dying and going to heaven!
I bet any of those cookies don't suck:) I especially think the white chocolate macadamia nut looks yummy.
The chuck milk chocolate look great! Thanks for the recipe.
triple chocolate chunk for me!! YUM YUM! And these butter cookies are SO CUTE!! I wish I had a fraction of your baking talent!!
The Butter Pecan sounds divine!
(And a word of caution...don't click on the little page icon next to the cookie name. Trust me. It's not a pretty sight [it's the nutrition facts].)
The sugar cookie is my favorite, delivered in my birthday month of April!
Triple Chocolate Pecan!
mmm white chocolate macadamia nut, without a doubt :)
Yum, chunky reeses peanut butter!
1. white chocolate macadamia nut sounds so delicious!!
2. triple chocolate pecan comes in at a close second.
3. my final choice would be chunky reeses peanut butter
wooo! the sugar free oatmeal cookies looks satisfyingly smooshy!
this is my first time on your blog...and I adore your sassy writing! yay!
I'm all about the chunky reese's peanut butter cookie!
Oh goodness the Februrary ones look DELICIOUS! (Because who can say no to something that involves TRIPLE chocolate?!?!?!)
Chunky Chocolate Pecan!
Oatmeal Cranberry Nut looks great to me!
Mmm, chunky milk chocolate! It just sounds good.
Oatmeal cranberry looks delicious!
Oooh I'm drooling over the butter pecan cookies. YUM!
Isn't it simply amazing how on the "vote for the best cookie recipe" there were so many ANONYMOUS voters and on this section, there are none.
Wow. Stunning.
These cookies look amazing! I featured them on my blog for my tutorial Tuesday! I hope that that is okay and that you will stop by! : ) I can't wait to make them!
http://yesmom8.blogspot.com/2009/12/tutorial-tuesday.html
XOXO,
Jaimie
I love these cute little cookies! That frosting sounds amazing, i will give it a try!
The button cookies look gorgeous in your post, but when I just made them they turned into a greasy, flat mess. I am an experienced baker, but I was so disappointed in the end results. I'm thinking maybe the flour is off or an ingredient was left out. Could you maybe give me a suggestion. I really love the looks of these cookies and would love to duplicate them. Thanks so much!
Dear Anon-
Thanks so much for the heads up! I'm so sorry they didn't work for you. Since I'm cooking at high altitude, I wonder if adding an additional 1/2c. of flour will help. I've made that variation to the recipe (since very few people are as high as I am in Colorado) and hope it works significantly better the next time around.
Do be sure you're cooking them at 300, rather than 350. It makes all the difference. :)
Happy Baking!
Hi!
I made these last night and after making a failed batch that were greasy and flat, I looked at the comments section and added an additional 1/2 cup of flour. This helped, however, my cookies fell flat as soon as I took them out and the "poof" became in indent. Not bad, I suppose, but do you have any recommendations for that? If I put any more flour in, the dough will crumble!
Delicious by the way. They were a hit at my office.
i adore the look of these cookies, and have tried repeatedly to make them. are you sure there isn't a missing ingredient? the dough doesn't want to form and once in the oven they fall flat and look greasy.
i want to make them so badly can you help me out?
-jessica
Okay girls-
I am sad and so sorry that the recipe is not working for you. I've checked and rechecked, and I don't know what the problem is. I'm going to try to make them again in my kitchen to ensure I've got the proper amount of ingredients.
A few thoughts:
Be SURE you are baking them at 300 degrees. You may even want to turn your oven down to 275. Because it's a shortbread-like dough, they will definitely melt if the heat is turned up too high.
When the recipe says "SOFTENED" butter, I should clarify that the term means "BARELY SOFTENED," as in just soft enough to crumble with a fork into the powdered sugar.
Finally, perhaps a bit of chilling will help those of you who are finding your cookies to melt? Not too much, because the dough just barely.barely sticks together as it is. But, a bit of chilling might help keep the cookies in place in the oven.
In my own kitchen, this was a very straightforward bit of cookie making. The batch was mixed, kneaded, cut and cooked without an melting or caving in. I hope you're able to perfect them in your own kitchens! I'll try to post any other thoughts/comments after I remake the batch.
Hugs and Baking Happiness,
~Brooke
Okay girls-
I am sad and so sorry that the recipe is not working for you. I've checked and rechecked, and I don't know what the problem is. I'm going to try to make them again in my kitchen to ensure I've got the proper amount of ingredients.
A few thoughts:
Be SURE you are baking them at 300 degrees. You may even want to turn your oven down to 275. Because it's a shortbread-like dough, they will definitely melt if the heat is turned up too high.
When the recipe says "SOFTENED" butter, I should clarify that the term means "BARELY SOFTENED," as in just soft enough to crumble with a fork into the powdered sugar.
Finally, perhaps a bit of chilling will help those of you who are finding your cookies to melt? Not too much, because the dough just barely.barely sticks together as it is. But, a bit of chilling might help keep the cookies in place in the oven.
In my own kitchen, this was a very straightforward bit of cookie making. The batch was mixed, kneaded, cut and cooked without an melting or caving in. I hope you're able to perfect them in your own kitchens! I'll try to post any other thoughts/comments after I remake the batch.
Hugs and Baking Happiness,
~Brooke
~*~ Help ~*~
Made these cookies last night (twice!) and while I'm an experienced baker - they fell flat. Not sure what you're doing differently that you posted above than the rest of us. It was a great dough! Wish they had turned out. Loved the photos!!!
Amelia sits at our computer and scrolls up and down looking at all of pictures of you on your blog. Isn't it fabulous to be so adored by a two year old?!
Just thought I would share that I made these per your original instructions and they came out fantastically! I did have to tweak the icing as I couldn't get it liquidy enough, but a tad more heavy cream and a bit of corn syrup and it came out as perfect as I needed :) This was the first batch of homemade cookies on my own and my husband loves them. Hopefully they'll be a hit at the cookie exchange tonight! Thanks for sharing the recipe :)
These cookies did not work for me - AT ALL. :( I tried them twice, and both times they just ended up in huge, flat ugly doughy piles. FAIL. and I'm still sad about it. They look so good!! What is your secret?
i had the same problem as the commenter above. i made 6 dozen for a cookie exchange tonight and although they turned out ok and are edible they certainly didn't pop up the way yours did. i followed the recipe! not sure what happened. i live in FL so, no high altitude problem here! also, i had to add quite a bit of corn syrup & heavy cream to get it to a good frosting consistency. i'm not sure how you got yours like that from your recipe because mine was clumpy and dry until i added more stuff. all in all they turned out nice but i was a little disappointed that they didn't puff up.
Agreed - massive fail. Mine melted into a flat greasy mess. Didn't even attempt the icing but it looks so pretty! Oh well.:)
Post a Comment